Date: 1/10/21 5:31 pm
From: Alvaro Jaramillo <chucao...>
Subject: Re: [southbaybirds] Possible Western Kingbird at Geng Road

Just because it is mentioned, in this thread, note that I do have a sparrows online workshop starting later on this month. But that the place where those events gets posted is the <southbaybirds-events...> .

Matthew Dodder through SCVAS is doing a gull workshop too.


Alvaro Jaramillo

<mailto:<alvaro...> <alvaro...>

From: <southbaybirds...> <southbaybirds...> On Behalf Of Lisa Myers
Sent: Sunday, January 10, 2021 4:44 PM
To: <idbirds...>
Cc: Luca <luucaa...>; <southbaybirds...>
Subject: Re: [southbaybirds] Possible Western Kingbird at Geng Road

Taking a few Birding classes is a great way to learn how to ID the birds too, but all the various venues are on hiatus until Covid is under control.

Lisa Myers

Los Gatos Birdwatcher/Let’s Go Birding

On Jan 10, 2021, at 1:30 PM, Brooke Miller via <> <idbirds...> <mailto:<idbirds...> > wrote:


Tropical Kingbird has a long, thick bill, and the yellow on its underside is brighter and goes further up the breast. In wintertime here, seeing a Western Kingbird would be much more unlikely than finding a Tropical Kingbird. I believe this is because Western Kingbirds spend our wintertime further south in the southern hemisphere, whereas Tropicals can be found year around in parts of Mexico. I think in the last few to several years we have had one to two Tropical Kingbirds found in winter in and around that area of Palo Alto.

You can find much more information from bird field guides, or online at <> .

Congratulations on your 100th bird!

Brooke Miller

On Jan 10, 2021, at 1:02 PM, Luca <luucaa...> <mailto:<luucaa...> > wrote:

Thanks, your help for the ID is much appreciated! How does one tell Western from Tropical?

It's kind of fun that my bird #100 happens to be a rare bird.


On Sun, Jan 10, 2021 at 12:58 PM Brooke Miller <idbirds...> <mailto:<idbirds...> > wrote:


That is a Tropical Kingbird that has been in the area for a while now (over a month, at least). Now that you have subscribed to South Bay Birds, you will be able to follow what birds people are seeings where. Welcome!

Brooke Miller

On Jan 10, 2021, at 12:52 PM, Luca <luucaa...> <mailto:<luucaa...> > wrote:

I saw what might be a Western Kingbird at Geng Road today, at 11:23am, on a tree next to the bathrooms. I include here some photos. I am a beginner birder (this would be my bird #100!), so I am not certain of the identification.




-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=- Links: You receive all messages sent to this group.
View/Reply Online (#23444):
Mute This Topic:
Usage Rules and more information about our lists is at: Birdwatching in Silicon Valley (
Interested in attending events in Santa Clara County? Subscribe to South-Bay-Birds (Events):
Trying to find a location mentioned in SBB? Try this Google Map:

Please be discreet in disclosing locations of nesting birds. Disclosure of nests for Owls and Raptors is prohibited.
Group Owner: southbaybirds+<owner...>
Unsubscribe: [<lists...>]

Join us on Facebook!