Date: 11/24/18 9:19 pm
From: Hendrik Herlyn <hhactitis...>
Subject: [obol] Fake "Emperor" Goose (hybrid) at Finley today
Hi all,

This morning, Pam Otley found an interesting goose on McFadden Marsh
(Finely NWR) that at first glance resembled an Emperor Goose. I was able to
relocate the bird a little later and get some distant photos. Apparently,
the same bird was seen by Deanna Emig south of Finley a few days ago. My
photos can be seen here:

The goose is about the same size as a Cackling Goose, with a mostly white
head and back of neck. The cheeks are mottled with black, and the front of
the neck is black, very similar to the pattern found in Emperor Goose.
However, the very short, stubby bill is entirely black. The body is mostly
dark brown, similar to a Cackler, and lacking the bluish-gray sheen and
heavy scalloping of a true Emperor Goose - to my eye, the back pattern is
right between Cackler and EMGO. The vent is mostly white (again similar to
Cackling Goose and unlike EMGO), with some black speckling. Unfortunately,
the bird remained in the water the entire time and I was unable to see the
leg color.

This bird bears a striking resemblance to one found at Fernhill Wetland,
Washington County, in mid-October this year. Its identity was discussed on
OBOL at the time, and Scott Carpenter posted a series of excellent pictures
(I'm forwarding the link below for comparison).

There was speculation that the Fernhill bird most like represented a hybrid
between Cackling Goose and Emperor Goose. It is my feeling that the same is
true for the Finley bird (I wonder if it could even be the same bird that
was at Fernhill earlier this fall). An extended Google search of various
hybrid combinations produced nothing that completely resembled my bird. The
closest are several known (captive) hybrids between Emperor and Barnacle
Goose, but their bills tend to look a little bigger than on the Finley
bird. I have found no pictures of hybrids between Cackling and Ross's or
Snow Geese that look anywhere near the Finley bird. The same goes for all
other combinations.
The overall pattern of Barnacle and Cackling Geese is somewhat similar, and
I believe the most likely ancestry for the Finley bird (as well as the
Fernhill bird) is Cackling and Emperor Goose. I am curious if others out
there have any additional insights. A fascinating bird - thanks, Pam, for
quickly getting the word out!

Happy wild goose chasing


Hendrik G. Herlyn
Corvallis, OR

*"Nature is not a place to visit. It is home." -- Gary Snyder*

Join us on Facebook!