Date: 10/5/17 5:43 pm
From: eric masterson <erictheirish...>
Subject: [NHBirds] Star Island report
I led the last of the 2017 weekend trips to Star Island this past weekend,
Friday to Sunday. It was postponed from the previous week due to high seas
on Friday Sep 22nd (Hurricane Jose). It might have been fun to be on island
with a scope, given the tremendous seabird haul that Jose brought to the
Cape, but getting there would have been inadvisable with seas 8-11 feet.
Anyway it worked out, as this was definitely one of the better weekends
since I have been leading these trips, although it is becoming difficult to
choose, there have been so many good ones.

The tiny island "smelled rare" from the get go and did not disappoint.
Michael Pahl remarked at dinner on the "Attu" gestalt of the place. The
total of 87 species was one of our highest, and high totals don't happen
without a few surprises, chief amongst which was an apparent western

16 species of warbler, including Blue-winged and the now relatively common
Cape May Warbler.
10 species of sparrow, including Lark and Clay-colored Sparrow.
American Oystercatcher
Lesser Black-backed Gull
A late Great Crested Flycatcher

And of course the western wood-pewee. The bird was picked up on call, which
in itself is odd for a fall pewee. They are usually fairly silent. It was
to my ears clearly wrong for eastern and responded aggressively to western
wood-pewee playback, but not to eastern. Fortunately, and courtesy of a
contentious vocal flycatcher in a previous fall that went unrecorded, I
went out and invested in recording equipment. I don't think an iPhone would
have clinched this bird - the call is critical to identification. I sent
some media out for review and the consensus opinion so far is that the bird
is a western wood-pewee, which will be a state first if accepted. In the
last two years, these trips have produced a state first lazuli bunting, a
state second chuck-wills-widow, and a state third white-winged dove, in
addition to numerous lesser rarities. Not bad for a 46 acre rock.

Thanks to Louis Bevier, Curtis Marantz, and Cin-ty Lee for feedback on the
ID, and all the participants who make these trips possible.

Saturday list
Sunday list

To Change your e-mail delivery settings (digest, daily, no mail) visit:
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "NHBirds" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to nhbirds+<unsubscribe...>
To post to this group, send email to <nhbirds...>
Visit this group at
For more options, visit

Join us on Facebook!