Date: 11/16/26 10:36 am From: Dan Mullarkey <dmullarkey7...> Subject: Re: [NHBirds] Halftime on the November county Challenge
Thanks for the update Pam. I'm enjoying the NCC and getting out on these
beautiful days. I haven't seen anything new lately but have greatly enjoyed
watching common mergansers fishing very successfully, and great looks at a
red-shouldered hawk - just trying to stay present with these treats while
waiting for something new to blow in.
I'm glad we've added the 5-year average, it's a good way to remove some of
the historical "bias", like data patchiness in the less birded counties.
Here's what I have calculated for county averages 2021-25:
Pam and I agree that there is no one best metric, no one score to rule them
all. That said, I'd like to float an idea for combining the two in a way
that works kind of like a handicap in bowling or golf competitions. We
could use the original metric and add a bonus or penalty for overperforming
or underperforming compared to 5 year trend, so:
As an example, if Merrimack hits 62% this year, their score would be 62 +
(62-58) = 66
and if Belknap hits 68% this year, our score would be 68 + (68 - 70.9) =
65.1. Which means Woodward better quit whining about cold temperatures and
get his butt in gear.
I'd like to get feedback on this third combo metric from anyone interested.
Happy birding all,
Dan Mullarkey
Gilford
On Mon, Nov 16, 2026 at 7:39 AM Pam Hunt <biodiva63...> wrote:
> I'm sure you're all at the edges of your seats waiting to hear how your
> county of choice is faring how that November is half over. Wait no longer,
> for I have a chart! (Apologies for the narrow first column with the county
> names, but I'm guessing you can figure them out).
>
> Rank B Nov 15 all time % Rank A 5-year % Rank B Ave Rank
> Belknap 88 0.587 2 0.924 5 3.5
> Carroll 64 0.408 10 0.688 10 10
> Cheshire 96 0.561 5 0.972 3 5
> Coos 81 0.544 7 0.912 7 7
> Grafton 84 0.477 9 0.808 9 9
> Hillsborough 104 0.578 3 0.959 4 3.5
> Merrimack 110 0.564 4 1.028 1 2.5
> Rockingham 156 0.551 6 0.915 6 6
> Strafford 102 0.531 8 0.878 8 8
> Sullivan 85 0.590 1 0.973 2 1.5
>
> Remember that there are two scoring systems being compared here. All time
> % refers to the current total as a percentage of all species ever seen in
> that county in November. 5-year %, on the other had, is the current total
> as a percentage of the average of the last five years of the NCC. The
> rationale for the latter is that it evens the playing field a little by not
> including a ton of historical records from heavily-birded counties, but
> still acknowledges the impressive efforts folks have put out in recent
> years.
>
> Is one system "better" that the other? Of course not, and your answer will
> likely depend on which county you're cheering for. Most counties don't
> change much, with the biggest difference being the flip of Merrimack and
> Belknap.
>
> Highlights in the last week, some already mentioned in this group, include
> an impressive waterfowl fallout in Grafton (including Common Eider!),
> Bullock's Oriole in Rockingham, Bohemian Waxwing (and multiple Golden
> Eagles) in Hillsborough, and American Golden-Plover in Carroll. I'm sure
> there are plenty of others for anyone who wants to crow or rave(n) about
> them,
>
> Two weeks to go. What remains to be found? And more importantly, will you
> find it?
>
> Good birding to all,
> Pam Hunt
> Concord
>
> --
> To Change your e-mail delivery settings (digest, daily, no mail) visit:
> https://groups.google.com/group/nhbirds/subscribe?hl=en > ---
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
> "NHBirds" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an
> email to nhbirds+<unsubscribe...>
> To view this discussion visit
> https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/nhbirds/<CAPZ2PUvEjgVZHKVj4h-i5djTxjseomODYpGJBXDDe65FXGfGpg...> > <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/nhbirds/<CAPZ2PUvEjgVZHKVj4h-i5djTxjseomODYpGJBXDDe65FXGfGpg...>?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer> > .
>