Date: 6/29/26 8:19 am From: Edge Wade <00000631c0031214-dmarc-request...> Subject: Re: Today Show Story on Birding
The link worked for me. Good story. I repeat, however, that Merlin in the
hands of a novice is as effective/accurate as a hammer in the hands of a
five-year old. Merlin is a wonderful tool, but it is not perfect.
Merlin cannot always distinguish the sounds coming from a good imitator
(like a European Starling) from the "real McCoy" for example.
Merlin may indicate it is picking up the vocalizations of a Northern
Mockingbird when it really is detecting part of a Northern Cardinal's
repertoire.
Lately, my Merlin has been indicating Tree Swallow when there are
definitely no swallows present. I haven't figured out what is triggering
that--maybe an insect?
And beware of other mis-indications--When I pish, Merlin often indicates it
is detecting a Bewick's Wren. It took several outings for me to figure
that out. Always be aware of habitat and range. Remember, in Missouri if
you hear hoofbeats, expect to see a horse, not a zebra.
Sometimes Merlin bounces back and forth between two species. Especially
here in Missouri, Merlin cannot always distinguish Carolina and
Black-capped Chickadee--often indicating both when listening to a single
bird. Knowing the expected range/occurrence of each should be your guide.
And, Merlin cannot always distinguish between an American Robin and a
Rose-breasted Grosbeak (which sounds like a robin who's had voice lessons).
The bottom line is sorta trust, but always verify!
Edge Wade
Columbia, MO
<1edgewade...>
On Mon, Jun 29, 2026 at 9:58 AM Mike Grant <
<000006656412c20d-dmarc-request...> wrote:
