Date: 11/15/24 4:33 pm
From: Barbara Volkle <barb620...>
Subject: [MASSBIRD] Pinnacle Rock (15 Nov 2024) 1 Raptors
Date: Fri, 15 Nov 2024 23:36:08 +000
From: <reports...>
Subject: Pinnacle Rock (15 Nov 2024) 1 Raptors


Pinnacle Rock
Malden, Massachusetts, USA
Daily Raptor Counts: Nov 15, 2024
-------------------------------------------------------------------

Species Day's Count Month Total Season Total
------------------ ----------- -------------- --------------
Black Vulture 0 0 0
Turkey Vulture 0 8 43
Osprey 0 0 16
Bald Eagle 0 3 36
Northern Harrier 0 1 5
Sharp-shinned Hawk 0 0 58
Cooper's Hawk 0 5 31
American Goshawk 0 0 0
Red-shouldered Hawk 0 2 3
Broad-winged Hawk 0 0 1
Red-tailed Hawk 0 5 13
Rough-legged Hawk 0 0 0
Golden Eagle 0 0 0
American Kestrel 0 0 8
Merlin 0 0 6
Peregrine Falcon 0 0 1
Unknown Accipiter 0 3 7
Unknown Buteo 0 0 2
Unknown Falcon 0 0 2
Unknown Eagle 1 1 1
Unknown Raptor 0 5 21

Total: 1 33 254
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Observation start time: 09:30:00
Observation end time: 16:00:00
Total observation time: 6.5 hours

Official Counter: Craig Jackson

Observers:

Visitors:
Thomas Monaco stopped by to discuss the hawk watch and what birds pass
through my site.


Weather:
Moderate to strong (3-4)NNW-NW winds with gusts up to 21 km/hr in the
morning and increasing to 28 km/hr in the last hour of the watch;
Temperature went from 2-8° C; Cloud cover -- for most of the watch the
only clouds were on the southern and western horizons going from 20-25%;
around noon the eastern sky started getting some clouds, but at no time was
more than 10% of the eastern sky cloudy

Raptor Observations:
Only one migrating raptor, a probable adult Golden Eagle, but a bird which
will have to be left as an unidentified eagle. I first saw what seemed to
be a brown buteo on the western horizon flying southwest toward the tower.
As it passed the tower (a kilometer away) the bird was clearly farther than
the tower and flying away. I assumed it was a large buteo since the head
was considerably shorter than the tail (eliminating in my mind the
possibility it was an immature Bald Eagle). However, although I initially
thought it was a Red-tailed Hawk the ID did not seem right. Since the tail
was not reddish, it should have shown "wing windows," but in fact the wing
pattern was very different. As the bird banked while soaring the dorsal
view of the bird was very different. From 1/3-1/2 of each outer wing was
dark, while the inner half of each wing and the mantle was a much paler
brown. As the bird was flying away and in a glide, the wings were
slightly curved downward. The bird hardly flapped at all, and when it did
the wing beats were not very deep. Finally, I did not note any whitish
markings on the wings or on the tail.

As I watched the bird fly away I went through the characteristics of
various raptors. Although the wings were curved downward, the wing pattern
and lack of crescents eliminated Red-shouldered Hawk. My only views of
Golden Eagle in over 20 years have been of immatures, and those have always
flown with noticeable dihedrals. Since this bird had no wing patches and
its wings were curved downward, and definitely not in a dihedral, I also
eliminated Golden Eagle in my mind. Thus, as the bird flew away I was
still in a quandary.

Looking at my copy of Dunne and Sutton's Hawks in Flight, I noted that
first year birds showed a somewhat similar dorsal pattern on their wings
with very dark outer wings contrasting with the lighter inner wings. Thus,
despite not noting a large head projection, I initially thought it must be
an immature Bald Eagle that doesn't show any white markings. Still, not
completely satisfied, despite the bird's wings not being a dihedral, I
decided to check the pictures of Golden Eagle in the same book. When I did
so, I saw that the dorsal view of the adult Golden Eagle's wings was even
more similar to what I had seen. On the following page I then noted
Dunne's statement "Curiously, the dihedral is rarely seen on the East Coast
.... Most Golden Eagles seen at coastal watch points fly flat-winged." I
was now pretty much convinced that the bird I had see was probably a Golden
Eagle.

Since I also had Liquori's Hawks at a Distance, I also checked that
reference as well. Although several of his photos of juvenile Bald Eagles
were similar to my bird, his photos of adult Golden Eagles were more so.
He also noted that "Golden Eagles typically show dropped wings ..."

Given all the above, I am pretty sure that the bird I saw had been an adult
Golden Eagle, but will record it as an unidentified eagle, since it is not
a certain ID.

Non-migrating raptors -- One adult Bald Eagle and an immature Red-tailed
Hawk

Non-raptor Observations:


Predictions:
Tomorrow's winds will again be from the NW, getting stronger around
noontime before moderating slightly. Sunday's winds will also be from the
NW but less strong. As NW winds are the best winds for this site,
notwithstanding the scarcity of raptors today, both day's hold the promise
of migrants.
========================================================================
Report submitted by Craig Jackson (<crleja1949...>)


More site information at hawkcount.org:https://hawkcount.org/siteinfo.php?rsite=239


 
Join us on Facebook!